Jamaican Curry Chicken Classic

This fragrant Jamaican curry chicken fills your kitchen with warm spices and the promise of something hearty and soul-satisfying. The chicken soaks up the punchy flavor from a marinade rich in green seasoning and curry powder then simmers in a creamy coconut sauce until fork-tender. This recipe honors Jamaican family tables and makes for a meal packed with nostalgic comfort and a bit of heat.

The first time I made this, my house was filled with a rich aroma so inviting that even my neighbors were knocking to ask what I was cooking. Now I crave it anytime I want a taste of home.

Ingredients

• Chicken thighs and drumsticks: provide juiciness and flavor. Choose organic chicken if possible for tenderness
• Jamaican green seasoning: gives a backbone of herbal brightness. Opt for a homemade mix with scallion and thyme if you can
• Jamaican curry powder: is the star with its peppery warmth. Make sure yours is vibrant yellow and freshly aromatic
• On Everything All-Purpose Blend: brings depth. Make a homemade version with sea salt and dried herbs for authentic taste
• Smoked paprika: amplifies color and subtle smokiness
• Sea salt: seasons every layer
• Extra virgin olive oil: helps achieve a golden sear
• Brown sugar: creates a caramelized base for the sauce
• Full-fat coconut milk: offers creaminess and mild sweetness
• Russet potatoes: absorb those spicy flavors and thicken the sauce. Pick firm potatoes without blemishes
• Carrots: bring subtle sweetness and color. Choose medium carrots for easy chopping
• Bell pepper: adds crunch and a pop of freshness. Look for one with glossy skin
• Fresh garlic and ginger: sharpen the flavor
• Scotch bonnet peppers: are traditional and give fiery heat. Handle with gloves and pick ones that are still firm and glossy
• Spring onions or scallions: add freshness and a pop of green
• Fresh thyme sprigs: infuse the sauce with a distinctly Caribbean aroma. Choose bright green stems
• Chicken stock: deepens the sauce and keeps everything juicy. Low sodium is best for seasoning control
• Jamaican pepper sauce: brings the heat. Use your favorite fiery sauce if you cannot find this
• Ground allspice: adds sweet earthiness
• Sea salt and black pepper: to taste at the end for balance

Step-by-Step Instructions

Marinate the Chicken:

Combine rinsed chicken with browning if using green seasoning salt all-purpose blend smoked paprika and curry powder. Massage well then place into a sealed bag or covered bowl. Marinate for at least three hours but overnight for best flavor. Let chicken come to room temperature before cooking

Brown the Chicken:

Add olive oil to a large skillet and heat. Stir in brown sugar and let it melt until it takes on a wet look then add the marinated chicken. Sear each side for several minutes until golden and set aside. This builds foundational flavor and a beautiful color

Burn the Curry Powder:

Add more oil to the same pan and sprinkle in the curry powder. Stir as it darkens and becomes fragrant. This crucial step unlocks the full spice character and color

Build the Curry Sauce:

Toss in garlic ginger scotch bonnets spring onions carrots and bell peppers. Sauté until fragrant and beginning to brown. Season with allspice salt and black pepper and stir well

Simmer Everything:

Pour in coconut milk chicken stock and pepper sauce. Let it come just to a boil to activate the spices. Add back the chicken along with potatoes crushed scallions and thyme sprigs. Lower the heat to a gentle simmer and cook for twenty to twenty five minutes until sauce thickens and the chicken is tender

Finishing the Curry:

Taste and adjust seasoning if needed. The sauce should be rich and velvety with enough gravy for your favorite side

Serve:

Dish up with steamed rice or vegetables. Top with chopped scallion or a sprinkle of red pepper flakes for extra heat if you like

Save

Every time I cook with scotch bonnet peppers I think of my grandmother carefully de-seeding them at the kitchen sink warning me about their sneaky heat yet encouraging me to not be afraid of bold flavors

Storage Tips

Cool leftovers fully before sealing in an airtight container. This curry lasts in the fridge for three to four days and reheats beautifully in the microwave or gently over the stove. Add a splash of chicken stock when reheating to revive the sauce and keep everything saucy and fresh

Ingredient Substitutions

No scotch bonnet on hand Use habanero or serrano peppers for a bit of heat though nothing matches the traditional flavor exactly

For a lighter option use chicken breast though it will be less juicy than dark meat

If authentic Jamaican curry powder is hard to find a blend of turmeric coriander cumin and a pinch of allspice can help supplement basic store-bought curry

Serving Suggestions

Serve with fluffy white or brown rice to soak up all the sauce

Pair with simple steamed greens or roasted plantains for a Caribbean-inspired meal

A side of warm roti or flatbread makes every bite more special and helps scoop up every last bit of curry

Save

Cultural and Historical Context

Curry chicken has roots tracing back to the Indian indentured laborers who settled in Jamaica bringing their spice traditions. Over generations Jamaican cooks put their own spin on the dish blending native herbs and scotch bonnet peppers. Today this curry remains a Sunday staple in many homes celebrated for its comforting familiarity and bold taste

Recipe FAQs

→ Why burn the Jamaican curry powder?

Toasting or 'burning' Jamaican curry powder in hot oil brings out its color and aroma, and helps mellow any raw flavors, making the finished dish richer and smoother.

→ What’s the best chicken cut to use?

Drumsticks and thigh pieces offer tenderness and depth of flavor, staying moist throughout slow simmering. Bone-in pieces are traditional and recommended for an authentic effect.

→ How spicy is it and can I adjust the heat?

Scotch bonnet peppers deliver significant heat; reduce the amount, remove seeds, or substitute with milder habanero or bell pepper for a gentler finish.

→ Is it possible to make this dairy or gluten-free?

This dish is naturally dairy-free due to coconut milk. For a gluten-free version, ensure all store-bought seasonings and sauces are labeled gluten-free.

→ What sides pair well with this dish?

Jamaican curry chicken is traditionally served over steamed rice, but also pairs beautifully with fried plantains, steamed vegetables, or roti for a satisfying meal.

→ Can I prepare it in advance?

Yes, the flavors deepen overnight. Store in an airtight container and reheat gently, adding a splash of stock if needed to keep the sauce silky.