Save
This creamy mashed potato recipe has been my family's ultimate comfort food for generations, delivering restaurant-quality results with a magical brown butter finish that transforms this simple side dish into something extraordinary.
I discovered the brown butter technique during a Thanksgiving disaster when I ran out of gravy. What started as a quick fix became our signature family favorite that guests now specifically request by name.
Ingredients
- Russet or Yukon Gold potatoes choose Yukon Golds for creamier texture or russets for fluffier results
- Whole head of garlic roasting brings out sweet mellow flavors that infuse throughout
- Heavy cream provides luxurious richness impossible to achieve with milk alone
- Whole milk balances the cream for perfect consistency
- Fresh thyme adds subtle earthy notes that complement the potatoes beautifully
- Butter both in the potatoes and as a brown butter finish for maximum flavor impact
- Extra virgin olive oil helps the garlic roast to golden perfection
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Roast the Garlic
- Cut one whole head of garlic in half horizontally, drizzle with olive oil, and roast at 400°F for 12 minutes until soft and golden brown. The garlic should be spreadably soft with a mellow sweetness that transforms the entire dish.
- Prepare the Potatoes
- Peel and quarter 4 pounds of potatoes, placing them in cold water before bringing to a boil. Cook for 20-25 minutes until fork tender but not falling apart. Starting with cold water ensures even cooking from the inside out.
- Rice or Mash
- Drain the potatoes thoroughly then immediately pass them through a potato ricer for silkiest texture or use a potato masher for a more rustic finish. Work quickly while potatoes are hot for best results.
- Add the Dairy Elements
- Incorporate the heavy cream, milk, butter, and seasonings while the potatoes are still hot. The warm potatoes will absorb the dairy better, creating a smoother texture and richer flavor profile.
- Brown the Butter
- Heat 3 tablespoons of butter in a small skillet over medium heat for 2-3 minutes, watching carefully until it develops a golden amber color and nutty aroma. Remove immediately to prevent burning.
- Serve with Flair
- Plate the mashed potatoes in a serving bowl, drizzle with brown butter, and garnish with fresh thyme leaves and freshly cracked black pepper for a professional presentation.
Save
The roasted garlic completely transforms these potatoes. The first time I made this recipe for my grandmother, she insisted I had used a secret ingredient she couldn't identify. Now at 92, she still demands these exact potatoes at every family gathering.
Potato Selection Secrets
The variety of potato you choose dramatically impacts your final texture. Yukon Golds deliver a naturally buttery flavor and creamy consistency making them my first choice for special occasions. Russets create a fluffier, lighter result that soaks up gravy beautifully. For everyday meals, I often use a combination of both for the perfect balance. Never use waxy red potatoes for mashing as they become gummy regardless of technique.
Troubleshooting Common Issues
If your mashed potatoes turn out gluey, you likely overworked them or used the wrong tool. Food processors and blenders are the enemy of good mashed potatoes as they rupture too many starch cells. Always use gentle hand tools like ricers or mashers. If potatoes seem too watery, return them to low heat in the pot for a few minutes to evaporate excess moisture while stirring constantly. For potatoes that are too thick, gradually add warm milk until you reach desired consistency.
Creative Leftover Transformations
Leftover mashed potatoes become an entirely new culinary canvas. Form them into patties and pan fry for crispy potato cakes for breakfast. Use them as a topping for shepherd's pie or cottage pie. Thin them slightly with chicken broth to create a hearty potato soup base. My family favorite is mixing leftover mashed potatoes with cheese and chives, then stuffing them inside bacon wrapped jalapeños for an incredible appetizer that disappears instantly at gatherings.
Save
Recipe FAQs
- → What potatoes work best for this dish?
Yukon Golds are ideal for creamy mashed potatoes due to their buttery texture and medium starch content. Russets are a good alternative if you prefer a fluffier result. Both varieties will work well with the garlic and brown butter flavors.
- → Can I make these mashed potatoes ahead of time?
Yes! You can prepare these up to 2 days in advance. Store them in an airtight container in the refrigerator, then reheat with a splash of milk or butter to maintain their creamy texture. They can also be frozen for up to 3 months—just thaw overnight in the fridge before reheating.
- → Why do my mashed potatoes sometimes turn out gluey?
Gluey potatoes usually result from overworking them, especially when using high-speed appliances like blenders or food processors. For best texture, use a potato ricer or hand masher, and mix gently when incorporating the dairy. Also, starting potatoes in cold water helps them cook evenly and prevents gumminess.
- → What makes brown butter worth the extra effort?
Brown butter transforms these mashed potatoes with its nutty, caramelized flavor that regular melted butter can't match. The process only takes 2-3 minutes—simply heat butter past melting until it develops golden-brown milk solids. This simple step adds remarkable depth and complexity to the final dish.
- → How can I make these mashed potatoes even more flavorful?
Beyond the roasted garlic and brown butter, try warming your dairy before adding it to help the potatoes absorb flavors better. Season at multiple stages (boiling water, after mashing, final tasting) for layered flavor development. For extra richness, incorporate a dollop of sour cream or cream cheese. Fresh herbs like chives, rosemary or additional thyme also enhance the final presentation and taste.
- → What can I do with leftover mashed potatoes?
Leftover mashed potatoes are incredibly versatile. Transform them into crispy potato pancakes by mixing with an egg and pan-frying. Use them as a topping for shepherd's pie, fold them into soups for added creaminess, make potato croquettes, or simply reheat with additional butter for a quick side dish.